Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

Reviews of Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

0 Whalton Lane, Key West, Florida, 33040, United StatesSee Hotel Details
Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages
Andrews Inn & Garden CottagesAndrews Inn & Garden CottagesAndrews Inn & Garden Cottages
Choose dates to check available rooms
We Price Match

Guest Reviews

9.3/10
Great
52 Reviews
Verified reviews
Location9.3
Amenities9.3
Service9.3
Cleanliness9.3
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(52)
Positive reviews(42)
Reviews with photos/video(16)
Guest User
Roma Room
Stay Date Sep 2025
Couple
10 Reviews
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Nov 3, 2025
Уютный двор. Удобная кровать и умеренный завтрак. Обязательно заранее бронируйте парковку для машины.
Translate
526heathl
Stay Date Jul 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Aug 18, 2026
It had been awhile since we had stayed here, and it is still as special as it has ever been. The guest service is impeccable. The surroundings are like an oasis. We stayed in the Roma room, plenty of space and a nice bathroom. The room is quiet and cool. The fans are a nice touch in the extreme heat. Bed was comfortable and towels were thick. The breakfast was ample and tasty. Andrews Inn makes Key West a more special place than it is already.
Response from Property: Thank you so much for your wonderful review and for choosing to stay with us again! We’re so happy to hear that Andrews Inn still feels just as special. It was a pleasure having you back, and we hope to welcome you again soon for another relaxing Key West getaway!
Tim P
Stay Date May 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jun 8, 2026
We have just returned from a 5 night stay at Andrews Inn and Cottages. Our stay was just perfect. The whole place is beautiful and very intimate with many little added touches which make it just like home from home. It is situated in the perfect central position for exploring old town on foot. With only 6 rooms it feels really personal and is beautiful quiet at night. Thank you for looking after us so well. We will definitely recommend you to all our friends and hope to return one day. Tim and Ali
6/7
Response from Property: Dear Tim and Ali, Thank you so much for your wonderful review. We’re so happy to hear that your 5-night stay with us was perfect and that you enjoyed the peaceful, intimate atmosphere of Andrews Inn and Cottages. It was a pleasure looking after you, and we truly appreciate your kind words and recommendation. We would be delighted to welcome you back one day.
Jonathan W
Stay Date Aug 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Sep 26, 2026
Warm welcome and had a lovely relaxing time away from the hustle and bustle of Duval st. The hosts are very welcoming and checkin was easy. Breakfast is super and the happy hour is welcomed extra. Key West itself was a bit marmite - some interesting highlights were Hemingway’s house and the little White House and lighthouse. Beaches were disappointing and Duval st is quite tacky in parts. 2 nights in Key West is ample. The whole area is really expensive for what you get. If you’re going - stay here - it’s really cute.
Response from Property: Thank you so much for choosing us for your stay, we are glad that we were up to your expectations!
Sightsee203786
Stay Date Aug 2026
Solo traveler
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Sep 18, 2026
Had a wonderful stay! Very clean. The couple that takes care of Andrews Inn were very gracious. Will definitely stay here again.
Response from Property: Thank you so much for your review! We're glad our friendly staff and cleanliness made a good impression. We would love to have you visit again.
becky R
Stay Date Aug 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Sep 15, 2026
Everything was amazing at this hotel. They were so attentive to us yet did not bother you at all. We're one block off Duval and yet it was a quiet oasis. The items at breakfast and happy hr were both plentiful and offered good varieties. We will definitely choose this place again hands down
Response from Property: Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re delighted that you had the perfect balance of fun and relaxation and enjoyed our peaceful oasis just steps from Duval Street. It’s also lovely to hear that breakfast and happy hour were highlights of your stay. We truly enjoyed having you and can’t wait to welcome you back to Andrew’s Inn!
jeraldbarnes
Stay Date Jul 2026
Family
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Aug 21, 2026
Small, intimate, charming with excellent location. Quiet and attentive in all regards. A nice get-a-way....and the hostess was excellent.
Response from Property: Thank you so much for your kind review! We're glad to hear your needs were met and that you enjoyed the peaceful, intimate atmosphere of Andrews Inn and Cottages. We hope to host you again!
BiaDolcePat
Stay Date Jan 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 18, 2026
I would give the Andrews Inn more stars but 5 is as high as you go! Izabella doesn't take your reservation She curates your stay She wanted to know the reason for Our Trip and some of the places we visited What to see in Key West. I mentioned I wanted to see The Cats at the Hemingway museum and that My Birthday was the reason for the trip. Only problem no rooms available when I first called for a room (end of October) So I went on the waiting list .... Then sometime later Izabella called and ... She said she had a room for us and The perfect room it was too! The room was in the back and it had a balcony which overlooks the Garden of The Museum. On My Birthday at Breakfast Izabella waited till I wasn't looking and brought out the most beautiful Chocolate Cake. Izabella and Lazselo Made Us feel like " Old Friends" and not just another Guest . We are already planning next year's trip.
Response from Property: Thank you so much for the beautiful review ,it really made us smile. We’re so glad the room worked out in the end and that you got to enjoy the balcony overlooking the Hemingway garden (and of course the famous cats!). It was a real pleasure meeting you and spending a little time together during your visit. We’ll be very happy to welcome you back next year.
Chad C
Stay Date Jan 2026
Family
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 13, 2026
What a wonderful little hideway! Staff is beyond friendly and attentive. With only a handful of rooms, you are made to feel like a priority. Room was clean and comfortable. 30 second walk to all that Duval Street has to offer. Highly recommended!
Response from Property: Thank you so much for your amazing words. It means a lot to hear that you felt well taken care of , that’s exactly the experience we hope to create for our guests. We’d be very happy to welcome you back anytime.
John O
Stay Date Jun 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jul 29, 2026
Location was great, very central and Duval street is only a few mins away. Rooms were lovely and clean and it was very quiet despite its proximity to town. Breakfast was lovely each morning with a good selection and happy hour was a nice touch each afternoon. We enjoyed exploring Key West on the complimentary bikes. The team were so friendly and we felt right at home. All the best. John & Maura
Response from Property: Thank you so much for these amazing words. We are super happy that we could offer you a comfortable stay and meet all your needs and expectations. We look forward to seeing you another time!
Chandler R
Stay Date May 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jun 15, 2026
Andrews Inn is a great little getaway in the heart of Key West. We stayed in the Malaga room which had a couch and a little patio that looked out at the Hemingway House. We were able to watch the cats from the patio which was nice. The bed was super comfortable, the AC worked great, and the room was very nice overall. One of the best things about this property is the central location. You are walking distance to almost everything you could want to do in Key West and for things that are farther, you can easily rent a golf cart from a place right down the street. Izabella was a great host and was so nice and friendly. She made me and my wife feel very welcome and even had our room ready for us early when we checked in. Breakfast was simple, but all of the food was good, we didn't need a large, elaborate breakfast, especially since it was hot when we were in Key West. The property is compact, but very pretty and it felt very private despite being right by Duval St. This is an excellent little place to stay and a great base to explore everything that Key West has to offer. We would definitely stay here again.
Response from Property: Thank you so much for this wonderful review! We’re so happy you enjoyed your stay in the Malaga room and that you got to watch the Hemingway cats from your patio — that’s such a special little Key West moment. It was truly a pleasure hosting you and your wife, and I’m so glad we could make you feel welcome and get you settled in early. We’re also happy you enjoyed the location, the room, and the peaceful feel of the property even being so close to Duval. Thank you again for choosing Andrews Inn. We would absolutely love to welcome you both back anytime!
Ericka B
Stay Date May 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jun 4, 2026
We love Andrews Inn! This was the 2nd time we have stayed here. The property is clean, the staff friendly and accommodating. It's very close to Duval but you would never know. It is so nice to take advantage of the free breakfast and Happy Hour daily. The room was cool (in June) and bed comfortable. We will be back.
Response from Property: Thank you, Ericka, for your kind feedback! We’re so glad you enjoyed our property, hospitality, breakfast, and Happy Hour. It was a pleasure having you stay with us again, and you’re welcome back anytime. Take care, The Andrew's Inn Team
luvs2travel_0107
Stay Date Mar 2026
Family
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Apr 29, 2026
My room was the Paris room Very comfortable bed, very clean just perfect for me as a single guest. The breakfast was very nice. Pleasant atmosphere and accommodating staff. I loved the night light in the bathroom. Didn’t get in the pool but loved setting by it in the multiple chairs available. There are lots of thoughtful things around the pool. Lots of mood lighting. You are within walking distance of restaurants and entertainment. I think you will like this little corner of Paradise
Response from Property: Thank you for this—really. I’m glad the Paris room felt right for you and that you noticed the small details. That’s exactly what we try to get right without overdoing anything. Nice to hear you enjoyed the pool area too, even just sitting there. It’s one of those spots that doesn’t need much—just a quiet moment and a good atmosphere. And yes, the location does most of the work for us. We’d be happy to have you back anytime.
436BG
Stay Date Mar 2026
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Apr 24, 2026
Yet another amazing stay thanks to Izabella, Laszlo and the Andrews Team. We are legacy stays and all of my previous reviews still hold true. It’s a big thing for us to consider an accommodation as a second home but that pretty much says it all.
Response from Property: Thank you so much for this—it truly means the world to us. Hearing you call Andrews Inn your second home is the highest compliment we could ever receive. It’s always such a pleasure welcoming you back, and knowing that your experiences continue to live up to your previous stays is exactly what we strive for every day. We’re so grateful for your continued trust and loyalty, and we can’t wait to have you back with us again soon.
Nina V
Stay Date Aug 2025
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Sep 30, 2025
My fiance and I stayed here at Andrew's Inn for our 5 year anniversary. From the cleanliness of the room to the accommodations, happy hour and delicious breakfast served every morning, we were right at home. We walked to Duval street almost every day we were there. We also got to hear the Hemingway Tour right from our balcony. This hidden gem is an untapped resource. And we definitely will be going back. Thank you to the staff for keeping this place as tidy as it was. And for being friendly and making us feel as comfortable as possible while staying with you. Ryan and Nina Sheehan
Response from Property: Happy 5-year anniversary again! We’re so honored you chose to celebrate such a special milestone with us here at Andrews Inn. It makes us so happy to hear that you felt right at home, enjoyed the breakfast and happy hour, and even got to soak up the Hemingway Tour from your balcony—that’s such a unique Key West treat! Thank you for your kind words about our team and the property. Keeping everything tidy and welcoming for guests like you is truly our joy. We’re delighted you discovered our little hidden gem and can’t wait to welcome you both back for more special memories in the future.