57 Flinders Ln, Melbourne, Victoria, 3000, AustraliaSee Hotel Details
Choose dates to check available rooms
We Price Match
1 night
Guest Reviews
8.2/10
Very good
109 Reviews
Unlike basic averaging, our rating system applies weighted calculations. We value verified reviews and newer guest experiences more strongly—so every rating reflects real, up-to-date stays.
Verified reviews
Location8.5
Amenities8.2
Service8.2
Cleanliness8.1
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(109)
Positive reviews(9)
Guest User
Superior One Bedroom Apartment
Stay Date Apr 2026
Business traveler
1 Reviews
8.5/10
Very good
Posted on May 7, 2026
Great location, simple and well equipped apartment for a short stay. Very spacious as well.
Response from Property: Thank you for your lovely review.We’re delighted to hear you enjoyed our convenient location and found the apartment spacious, well equipped, and comfortable for your stay. It’s wonderful to know the apartment suited your needs so well.We truly appreciate your feedback and hope to welcome you back again soon at Punthill Manhattan.
Lorenzo Lewis
Superior One Bedroom Apartment
Stay Date Jan 2026
Couple
5 Reviews
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 25, 2026
This place is simply amazing. The location the access the size almost 55 square meters.
Note: there is construction happening next door which creates noise and light pollution but we were informed prior to booking so all good.
There is a dishwasher and washing machine.
I would highly recommend this place assuming the avg night rate stays around 110usd/night.
Response from Property: Hi Lorenzo,Thank you for your wonderful feedback! We’re thrilled to hear you enjoyed the apartment size, location, and facilities, including the dishwasher and washing machine. It’s also great to know that the prior notice about the nearby construction helped manage expectations.We really appreciate your recommendation and hope to welcome you back for another stay in the future.Kind Regards,Leshae
Guest User
Superior One Bedroom Apartment
Stay Date Jan 2026
Couple
1 Reviews
8.0/10
Very good
Posted on Feb 11, 2026
Great location and friendly staff. The room had everything we needed but the cleanliness was slightly lacking: cutlery and glasses were not really clean and the washing machine left a lot of residue on my clothes. That said overall I had an excellent stay.
Response from Property: Hi there,Thank you for your lovely feedback. We’re so pleased to hear you enjoyed our great location and found our team to be friendly and welcoming. It’s also wonderful to know the apartment had everything you needed and that you had an overall excellent stay.We do apologise, however, that the cleanliness of some items didn’t meet expectations. Cutlery, glassware and appliances should always be thoroughly checked, and we’re sorry to hear about the residue from the washing machine. Your comments have been shared with our housekeeping and maintenance teams so we can address this promptly and ensure it doesn’t happen again.Kind Regards,Leshae
Guest User
One Bedroom Apartment - Stair Access
Stay Date Oct 2025
Family
2 Reviews
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Dec 20, 2025
Stayed with my father in a double basement room for a week. The apartment was spacious and in a great location near Fitzroy Gardens and lots of restaurants. This was our second stay and would certainly return. Staff were really helpful.
Response from Property: Thank you for sharing your feedback! We’re delighted that you and your father enjoyed your stay, and it’s wonderful to hear that you appreciated the spacious apartment, great location, and helpful staff. We’re especially thrilled that this was your second stay and that you’d choose to return again, we look forward to welcoming you back soon!Kind Regards,Leshae
Guest User
Superior One Bedroom Apartment
Stay Date Jul 2025
Couple
18 Reviews
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Nov 11, 2025
The rooms are spacious and the staff are attentive. The location is great as well.
Response from Property: Thankyou for taking the time to review, we're so glad you enjoyed our spacious rooms and great location, and that the staff took good care of you! See you next time. Michaela - Hotel Manager
phatdonejames
Superior One Bedroom Apartment
Stay Date Jan 2025
Couple
4 Reviews
8.0/10
Very good
Posted on Feb 18, 2025
The location is good, but when we arrived at 2 pm, we couldn’t check in and had to wait 2 hours more. Plus there’s a terrible construction noise right next to our room every morning. Other from that the room has everything.
Response from Property: Dear James,We're glad your experience at Punthill Manhattan was positive and look forward to welcoming you back to the hotel. We do apologise for the delay you experienced in gaining access to your room, and for the disruption due to the ongoing construction project at 51 Flinders. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. Warm regards,Craig | Hotel Manager