Unlike basic averaging, our rating system applies weighted calculations. We value verified reviews and newer guest experiences more strongly—so every rating reflects real, up-to-date stays.
Verified reviews
Location9.1
Amenities9.0
Service9.0
Cleanliness9.1
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(57)
Positive reviews(38)
Reviews with photos/video(8)
Negative reviews(1)
re_ee
Room, Private Bathroom (Tidd's Room # 4)
Stay Date Nov 2025
Family
1 Reviews
7.0/10
Posted on Dec 15, 2025
Location is good if you're going to the Mercersburg Academy. 貴,性價比低,很低。
My husband and I have lived in the Mercersburg area for about 6 years and we decided to go to the Inn for breakfast on a lazy fall morning. We were pleasantly greeted with the beauty of the surroundings privately tucked into the landscape and by the server, Corey, who was attentive to just the right degree. The breakfast of French toast, eggs, bacon and toast was excellently prepared and served on a properly warmed plate. The French toast was a delicate balance between the soft soufflé of the eggs and the perfectly caramelized crust covered with just a sprinkle of confectioners sugar which was delightfully just the right amount of sweet. My only complaint is that I did not find this delightful Inn six years earlier. I won’t wait another six years to enjoy an evening dinner.
Response from Property: Thanks for your feedback! We're thrilled you enjoyed your breakfast, especially the French Bread Custard. Our team works hard to make guests feel at home, and they'll be delighted to hear that you appreciated the breakfast and your overall experience. We're always looking to improve and will take your comments into account. We can’t wait to welcome you back for dinner!
Guest User
Stay Date Dec 2025
Other
8.0/10
Very good
Posted on Jan 3, 2026
We had a great stay and overall a good experience staying here. The staff were all very nice and accommodating. The room was nice, pretty comfortable and overall had everything we needed. We stayed in one of the rooms in the carriage house. The shared kitchen is a little odd and could be much nicer with some focused attention. We didn't need the space so it wasn't much of a detractor for us but if you plan on using it it's not really stocked. We ate dinner one night and had two breakfasts while staying. The dinner was pretty good, especially considering the reasonable prices. Both breakfasts were really good with several options to choose from, and the service was nice as well. Overall a good experience and we would stay here again.
ps1972
Stay Date Apr 2025
Couple
6.0/10
Posted on May 17, 2025
We recently booked this inn for a couples weekend. The innkeepers try to make one feel at home. We appreciated the little touches like cookies when we arrived and a little goody to-go bag when we checked out. The inn is beautiful. The architecture is magnificent. We know there is a great deal of upkeep on a building like that and we appreciate their efforts to preserve it. Our experience might have been different if we had stayed in the inn itself, but we booked a room in the carriage house. If we had known there was no inside entrance to the second floor, we would not have made reservations there. Please see the picture of the steps we had to traverse to access our room. We want to let other travelers know of these steps. Our room was comfortable. There is a window air conditioning unit which was a bit noisy, but we were provided with earplugs. Also, we felt like our bed sloped, so we slept with our heads at the foot of the bed. We took our breakfast daily in the inn, and it was very good. We sampled the quiche, scrambled eggs, and French toast custard. Our server was attentive. Overall, we would be able to give our stay a better rating perhaps if our accommodations had been in the inn instead of the carriage house.
Response from Property: Thank you for your feedback. We are delighted to hear that you enjoyed your stay. Our team takes great pride in ensuring our guests feel at home, and they will be pleased to learn that you appreciated the breakfast and your overall experience. We are committed to continuous improvement and will carefully consider your comments. We look forward to welcoming you again when you are in the area.
Mary C
Stay Date Jul 2025
Family
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Aug 5, 2025
Wedding venue with out of state guests. All were extremely impressed with the venue, the hospitality, the food and the staff. Perfect.
Response from Property: Thank you for leaving such a lovely review of the Mercersburg Inn. Our entire team has read it, and it truly motivates us to keep striving to provide top-notch service and accommodations. We hope to welcome you back soon!
mbrappel
Stay Date May 2025
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jun 27, 2025
Very comfortable bed. Spotlessly clean room. We stayed on the third floor of this huge building. There is no lift so don’t overpack if you choose the upper floor. The outside temperature was blistery hot when we were there and the portable fan in the closet was extremely useful. We were greeted with two bottles of water and departed with a goodie bag for the road. Breakfast was delicious. Checkout was 11am. During our stay the restaurant and tavern were closed so we went to the James Buchanan Hotel restaurant for a surprisingly great meal. We would definitely return to both of those places.
Response from Property: Thank you for your feedback. We are delighted to hear that you enjoyed your stay. Our team takes great pride in ensuring our guests feel at home, and they will be pleased to learn that you appreciated the breakfast and your overall experience. We are committed to continuous improvement and will carefully consider your comments. We look forward to welcoming you again when you are in the area.
98lisag
Stay Date May 2025
Traveling with friends
8.0/10
Very good
Posted on Jun 3, 2025
The Inn was lovely. Our room was extremely comfortable. I slept like a baby - really comfortable bed, linens and pillows. However, my husband had opened the window and woke up due the morning traffic noise. My advice is turn on the air conditioner in the room to ensure a good night's sleep. My sea bass dinner was truly delectable. Others raved about their duck and scallop dinners. My husband was disappointed with his pasta meal but I am honestly surprised that he ordered it, considering he makes pasta from scratch so his expectation from a non-Italian restaurant was very high. The creme brulee was over the top delicious. Friendly staff. Fascinating history - a turn of the century inn with original Tiffany fixtures as well as period pieces from the original family. Great location. The porches, library, bar, and game room provided lots of space to unwind, relax. and enjoy conversations with friends. Sweet departure bag was a surprising treat. Thank you!
Response from Property: We sincerely appreciate your feedback and are pleased to learn that you enjoyed your stay. Our team is dedicated to providing a comfortable environment for our guests, and they will be gratified to hear your words about accommodations, dinner, and overall experience. We remain committed to ongoing improvement and will thoughtfully consider your suggestions. We look forward to hosting you again during your next visit.
tinat780
Stay Date Sep 2024
Couple
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Oct 22, 2024
Second time here. We were once again cycling The Western Maryland Rail Trail. This beautiful inn is just over the border in PA. Lovely place. This time we had room 10 on the 3rd floor. Beautiful room with period furniture and very comfy bed. Tomi, the innkeeper graciously let us store our bikes in the back hall. The location is also perfect to ski at Whietail so this will be our “ go to” for ski season. Had dinner in Byron’s dining room which was every bit as good as our first experience. They even made me a gluten free waffle at breakfast. Ramsey was our server at breakfast. A sweetheart. Lots of fun playing pool in the game room after dinner.
Response from Property: We appreciate your fantastic review of our Inn and staff. Your kind words encourage us to stay on the right path and keep aiming for excellence. We eagerly anticipate your next visit.
kathbmcclure
Stay Date Sep 2024
Solo traveler
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Oct 3, 2024
I can’t say enough good things about this b&b. I used self check in as I arrived late and filled out my breakfast preferences before heading to my room. Bet of airbnb & hotel rolled into one. The road can be a little loud, but no worries, they have ear plugs by the bed. I was sent on my way with a goodie bag! That is the best! And on top of it all, I left my phone charger, she found it and mailed it back to me on her dime. 5 Stars is not enough!
Response from Property: Thank you for sharing your experience. We're so glad you found us and enjoyed your stay. We love it when new guests discover us and become part of our extended Inn family! We look forward to welcoming you back!
Dane G
Stay Date Jan 2025
Family
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Feb 24, 2025
I surprised my husband with an overnight stay here for his 35th birthday and it was a wonderful experience. The room was beautiful, the personal touches like the complementary box of chocolates and departing gift bag were incredibly thoughtful, and the included breakfast was delicious (highly recommend the spinach quiche!). We will be back- thanks for the exceptional hospitality Tomi, Steven. 10/10 recommend!
Response from Property: What a wonderful description of your stay! Thanks so much. It's awesome that you discovered us and had a great stay and food. Each of your words encourages us to maintain our service quality and enhance it greatly day by day. We look forward to your next visit!
yantolita
Stay Date Dec 2024
Solo traveler
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jan 20, 2025
I stayed at the inn to be close to Whitetail Ski Resort. The Garden Room is suitable for a solo traveler, and the sitting rooms on the first floor are charming. I enjoyed very good meals there (dinner, breakfast). The staff people were friendly, helpful, and professional. I would stay there - and eat there - again without hesitation.
Response from Property: We appreciate your fantastic review of our Inn and staff. Your kind words encourage us to stay on the right path and keep aiming for excellence. We eagerly anticipate your next visit.