Unlike basic averaging, our rating system applies weighted calculations. We value verified reviews and newer guest experiences more strongly—so every rating reflects real, up-to-date stays.
Verified reviews
Location9.2
Amenities8.7
Service8.9
Cleanliness9.1
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(1424)
Positive reviews(1344)
Reviews with photos/video(225)
Friendly front desk staff(52)
Secluded lake view(40)
Clean pool(30)
Great swimming pool(30)
Perfect for business trips(24)
Close to metro(18)
Has French windows(7)
Negative reviews(80)
Aarti Narotam
Deluxe Lake View Room-King Bed
Stay Date Sep 2025
Solo traveler
4 Reviews
7.5/10
Posted on Oct 21, 2025
Lovely hotel. Some parts of the room bathroom and pool bathroom are getting old. But overall a good stay.
Response from Property: 尊敬的賓客:真誠感謝您的點評,我們會更注重此方面的細節,為了您下次的 到來,我們將會做得更好!
Guest User
Deluxe Lake View Room-King Bed
Stay Date Feb 2025
Couple
14 Reviews
6.0/10
Posted on Mar 25, 2025
We went to the hotel to have a *relaxing* time for 4 days-3nights; that was our purpose when booking the China Grain Hotel, next to a big park with view on a lake, and far from the city centre: to enjoy a relaxing time.
We were happy to arrive and discover our room. All in all clean (except for the scale; VERY dirty...). However the lobby was left VERY DIRTY (as it can be seen on the picture) the whole night! This is inadmissible in a hotel of such standing.
The bad moment came the next morning when we literarily got scolded by an employee/manager in the restaurant at breakfast for preparing taking out the food we had left (in order to not waste any); her manners were terrible even if the hotel has a policy of not taking out food left (which apparently was not true since there was a sign saying: don't waste, take out your food).
The matter would have been easily forgotten if she only had nicer manners and just let us know it was not allowed at the China Grain Hotel (whereas at some other 4- and 5-star hotels, it is absolutely accepted), but instead she was aggressive in her manners, and just destroyed the nice mood we had for the rest of our stay ... since we had booked for 3 breakfasts (we tried to cancel them, but it wasn't possible). The food at the breakfast wasn't very pleasant, there was no skill shown in making those dishes, and lots of it was mainly frozen food warmed up! Highly suggesting future clients to avoid their breakfast, there are no healthy options, and we are being refused when we ask if some personal preferences could be made, such as an omelette or scrambled eggs rather than just a heavily fried sunny egg (quite dry ... and cold, because they had been done in large quantities).
It was not a terrible experience, but it was definitely enough to recommend others to look for other/better options. Location is very good, the rest was disappointing for a 4- 5-star hotel.
Response from Property: Dear Guest;Thank you for taking time out of your busy schedule to share your experience with us.We place great importance on your feedback regarding the cleanliness of our public areas and will immediately take steps to improve it. We sincerely apologize for the minor issue you during your stay at our hotel while dining, and the relevant departments have already made corrective plans to ensure that such problems do not occur in the future. We take your feedback very and will do our utmost to improve the service issues of our staff to meet your and other guests' needs and expectations. If you have any other questions or suggestions, please feel free contact our customer service team. Thank you once again for your review and wish you a pleasant day!
Guest User
Deluxe Lake View Room-King Bed
Stay Date Sep 2025
Couple
5 Reviews
8.0/10
Very good
Posted on Nov 19, 2025
Oktried and tested, reliable, reasonably priced, solid service
Response from Property: 尊貴的賓客您好,感謝您入住上海中谷小南國花園酒店並對我們的服務滿意,也非常感謝您對我們的支 持與厚愛,我們一定會更加努力,竭誠為您提供更為優質的服務,期待您下次光臨!謝 謝!PS. 如果您是對我們的服務很滿意,評分應該是 5 分。謝謝您的關注
Guest User
Guestroom (Affiliated Building)
Stay Date Oct 2024
Family
3 Reviews
9.0/10
Great
Posted on Dec 9, 2024
Great view to the park and also really close to the subway. But the hotel is a little bit old but still has good equipped rooms.
Response from Property: Dear guest, thank you for staying at Shanghai Zhonggu Xiao Nan Guo Garden Hotel and being satisfied with our service. Thank you for your support and love. We will work harder to provide you with better service and look forward to your next visit! Thank you! PS. If you are satisfied with our service, the rating should be 5 points. Thank you for your attention!
Guest User
Guestroom (Affiliated Building)
Stay Date Apr 2025
Family
17 Reviews
8.5/10
Very good
Posted on May 5, 2025
I had a fantastic stay at this hotel! The service from the receptionist was exceptional — friendly, professional, and very accommodating. I arrived earlier than the standard check-in time, but they kindly allowed me to check in early without any hassle. The entire check-in process took less than a minute, which was incredibly efficient and appreciated after a long trip.
Response from Property: Dear Guest;Hello! Thank you for choosing to stay at China Grain Hotel and for your satisfaction with our service. We are also very grateful for your and affection for us. We will definitely work harder to provide you with even better service. We look forward to receiving your full 5-star recognition the next time you stay with through our outstanding quality and sincere service.
Guest User
Exceptional Lake-View Double Bed Room
Stay Date Nov 2025
Business traveler
3 Reviews
7.5/10
Posted on Dec 13, 2025
Quite nice hotel n room quite spacious
Response from Property: 尊貴的賓客您好,感謝您入住上海中谷小南國花園酒店並對我們的服務滿意,也非常感謝您對我們的支 持與厚愛,我們一定會更加努力,竭誠為您提供更為優質的服務,期待您下次光臨!謝 謝!PS. 如果您是對我們的服務很滿意,評分應該是 5 分。謝謝您的關注
Guest User
Deluxe Lake View Room-King Bed
Stay Date Nov 2024
Family
1 Reviews
8.5/10
Very good
Posted on Dec 18, 2024
I recently stayed at the China Grain Hotel and was very delighted. The pricing is excellent, offering great value for money.
The staff were attentive, professional, and went above and beyond to ensure us a comfortable stay.
Overall, it’s a great choice if you’re looking for a luxurious experience at a reasonable price. Highly recommended!
Response from Property: 尊貴的賓客您好,感謝您入住上海中谷小南國花園酒店並對我們的服務滿意,也非常感謝您對我們的支 持與厚愛,我們一定會更加努力,竭誠為您提供更為優質的服務,期待您下次光臨!謝 謝!PS. 如果您是對我們的服務很滿意,評分應該是 5 分。謝謝您的關注!
Guest User
Guestroom (Affiliated Building)
Stay Date Jul 2024
Solo traveler
1 Reviews
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Aug 27, 2024
Service was great 👍🏻
Response from Property: Dear guest, thank you for your stay and recognition of the hotel service!
Guest User
Guestroom (Affiliated Building)
Stay Date Sep 2024
Business traveler
42 Reviews
9.5/10
Amazing
Posted on Oct 21, 2024
Great gym. But the staff is overwhelmed and has less than ideal equipment to provide 5 star service
Response from Property: Dear guests: Thank you for choosing Shanghai China Grain Hotel, it is a great honor to serve you, thank you for your recognition of our, for your suggestions we will seriously consider and improve, hope in your next stay to provide you with a satisfactory experience, looking forward to your stay again.
Anonymous User
Deluxe Lake View Room
Stay Date Feb 2024
Family
2 Reviews
6.0/10
Posted on Mar 8, 2024
Could be a good hotel, but staff lacks the required attention to detail.
Response from Property: Dear guest: Hello! Thank you for your comments on our hotel, we will work harder to improve the facilities and service standards, to bring you better service!
Zhongguoren
Guestroom (Affiliated Building)
Stay Date May 2023
Business traveler
96 Reviews
7.5/10
Posted on Jun 30, 2023
the facility is a little bit old but the surrounding environment is really good.
Response from Property: Dear guest: Hello! Thank you for your encouragement and support, we will work harder! Thanks for your continuous support! Wish you peace!
Guest User
Deluxe Lake View Room-King Bed
Stay Date Nov 2024
Couple
2 Reviews
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jan 4, 2025
It was clean
Response from Property: 尊敬的賓客:您好!非常感謝您的入住與讚賞!很高興能為您的出遊帶來美好的時光。 您的讚賞給予酒店很大的鼓舞,也是我們進步的動力,我們會繼續保持熱忱,致力讓每一位賓客享有賓至如歸的入住感受,熱切期待您的再次光臨!歡迎您再回來體驗,祝生活愉快!
Guest User
Guestroom (Affiliated Building)
Stay Date May 2024
Business traveler
1 Reviews
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jun 16, 2024
all good
Response from Property: 尊敬的賓客: 您好!感謝您對我們的全五分評價,我們會帶着您的鼓勵和支持繼續努力, 相信我們一定會做的更好!感謝一直的支持!祝順安!
mengd
Deluxe Lake View Room-Two Beds
Stay Date Sep 2025
Family
8 Reviews
4.5/10
Posted on Oct 8, 2025
This is a difficult stay to review.
Seven years ago today, we stayed at the Xiao Nan Guo Hotel. The environment and service were excellent. Staying there again is truly unbearable.
I was devastated. The mirror was directly across from the bed, and the front desk told me it was nothing and said I was the first to bring it up (what? Do you think I'm a bother? And I smoke… I was speechless).
We upgraded our room, but the lights in the room didn't work either. They flickered when I turned them on, and they were too dim when they turned them off… I even scanned the QR code to leave a complaint with the general manager, but I'm not sure if they'll improve it! I won't be back! I really won't be back!
Show OriginalGoogle Translated
Response from Property: Dear guest, hello! Thank you so much for sharing your experience with us and for providing valuable feedback and suggestions. We've made timely improvements. We weren't able to leave you with a perfect memory this time, but we hope to make up for it next time (give us a chance!). We're working hard, and we look forward to seeing you there! We wish you all the best!
M526108****
Deluxe Lake View Room-King Bed
Stay Date Aug 2025
Other
1 Reviews
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Oct 2, 2025
The place was quiet, with large, clean, and bright windows. The customer service staff were friendly and polite, and the breakfast was also quite satisfactory.
Show OriginalGoogle Translated
Response from Property: Dear guest: Hello, thank you for your review! The hotel advocates "careful service". We are carefully discovering opportunities to provide you with services and provide you with a more satisfactory and comfortable rest environment! Your satisfaction is our pursuit! Looking forward to your visit again.