Our server was so patient and kind with our little one. It really put us at ease and let us actually enjoy the meal.

Cozy little family-run place by the water. Friendly folks. I was glad to see a few gluten-free choices on the menu. Tried the GF pasta special&mdash;the texture was spot on, which can be tricky. A solid, simple meal in a nice setting.

The cheese fondue was so cozy for sharing. The roasted brussel sprouts and filet mignon were a nice touch. Felt like a warm, comforting meal, though it was a bit heavy by the end.

Loved the vibe here! That photo wall by the door was such a cute touch. My friends and I had to stop for a quick pic before we even sat down. Made for a fun start to our catch-up dinner.

The new chef&#39;s Food Network background shows. The meatballs and garlic bread were a great start. I really appreciated how fresh the ingredients tasted, especially in the tomato sauce. You could tell it was made that day.

Server was super helpful with suggestions, really knew the menu. Everything came out at a nice pace, never felt rushed or forgotten. Made for a relaxed dinner.

Booked the private room for a big group birthday. The staff handled everything smoothly. For 40 people, the price per head was really fair considering the quality of the food and the service. No hidden fees or anything.

Love the old-school diner feel here. The portions are huge! Got the classic patty melt and it was exactly what I wanted. Crispy bread, juicy patty, lots of cheese. A solid, no-fuss spot for a big lunch.

Been coming here for years, and the pizza never disappoints. The crust is always perfectly crisp, and the cheese is so fresh. Honestly, it&#39;s my go-to spot in the neighborhood.

The steak sandwich here is simple but so satisfying. I like how the space feels open and airy, with those big windows letting in all the light. It&#39;s a nice spot to just sit and enjoy a meal without feeling rushed.

The fresh linguini with shrimp was the star. Pasta had a great bite, and the shrimp were cooked just right, not rubbery at all. The sauce was light but flavorful. That&#39;s what I came for. The sommelier&#39;s timing felt a bit rushed, but the food itself was spot on.

They always remember my name and what I usually order. It&rsquo;s that kind of personal touch that makes you feel like a regular, even if you&rsquo;re not. Really nice vibe.

The clam chowder here is solid. Broth is light, not too heavy, and they don&#39;t skimp on the clams.

The grilled octopus was pretty good, tender with a nice char. Seafood pasta was decent too. It&#39;s a cozy spot, though a bit on the pricey side.

Great spot on Main Street for a casual bite. I grabbed a drink at the bar and really liked the energy there. The vibe was just right.

First time trying this place and loved the outdoor seating by the water. The old brick building and that vintage door at the entrance gave it a cool vibe. Perfect for a summer evening.

Rose was a total blast, super energetic and really made our night. The food was solid, and honestly the view is just insane. Prices felt fair for what you get. Solid spot.

Had the blackened swordfish. The fish itself was so fresh, you could really taste it. The seasoning was light, which I appreciated. It came with a simple side of grilled vegetables, all very crisp. A nice, clean meal. The view from our window table was a bonus.

The salmon was really fresh, and they had these pretty fresh flowers on the tables. It was a nice, bright space for our group.

Service was pretty good. The staff was friendly and attentive. They even swapped the bun on my lobster roll for a thinner one when I asked. A nice touch.

The staff was so nice and attentive. Our waitress gave great suggestions, and when it got a bit cool outside, she brought over a heater without us even asking. Made the whole evening really comfortable.

The Nova Scotia eggs benedict had a generous portion of salmon, which was nice. Home fries were cooked just right.

The garlic knots here are seriously good. So soft and buttery, with just the right amount of garlic. We also tried the calamari, which was crispy and not rubbery at all. Portions are huge for what you pay, which is always a plus.

Nice open space inside, felt comfortable. Food was decent, nothing fancy but reliable. Good option for a straightforward meal on the island.

Quick lunch spot. Got the chicken sandwich. Came out fast, which is key for me. Bread was fresh, chicken was decent. Not the cheapest but you pay for the speed. Good for a quick bite between meetings.

Been coming here for years between flights. The lemon pepper wings are always just right - crispy, not too salty. Carrots are a nice touch. It&#39;s my go-to spot in the terminal for something reliable.

Monique was our server and she was so lovely. Her kind, attentive service made the whole dinner feel relaxed and easy. It&rsquo;s nice when the staff genuinely seems to enjoy helping you.

Good spot for a working lunch. The window seats have great natural light, which is nice for focusing. I had the chicken sandwich and a coffee while getting through emails. Service was prompt, didn&#39;t feel rushed. The wifi is solid.

Find the best places for Dinner in Islip. Explore 1632 spots with authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and book your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Dinner in Islip

Ayhan's Shish-Kebab Restaurant

Salvatore's

Piccolo

Hudson Grille

La P'tite Framboise

Revel Restaurant & Bar

Sign of the Whale

Waterzooi Belgian Bistro & Oyster Bar

Giorgios

Sherwood Diner

Satelite Pizza

Gray Goose

Paci Restaurant

Mama Lisa Restaurant

The Bellport

Avino's Italian Table

Main Street Cafe

Rockin' Fish

Whales Tale

The Ritz Cafe

Country House

Crabby Amy's,

Trattoria Vivolo

Lake Grove Diner

Uncle Joe's Pizza

Pines Bistro

Cherry's On The Bay

Buffalo Wild Wings

The Palm Bar & Grille

Loft