THE 10 BEST Restaurants in Matelica

Recommend restaurants in Matelica for January

Updated in 2026

Il Lusitano

4.7/5

22 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

TheForkUserWe received a warm welcome and a friendly smile. The menu was comprehensive but as it was lunch we didn’t want a big meal - mind you the servings of what we had were very generous (and delicious)! The house white was also very reasonable.

Agriturismo FonteRosa

5/5

37 Reviews

$$-$$$

Reservation Available

Caveau del Capitano - Enoteca Ristorante

4.4/5

10 Reviews

$

Western-style

Ray Caffè

4.3/5

10 Reviews

$

Western-style

Bo Bar Ristopub

4.7/5

39 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

TheForkUserLoved the super chilled vibe, friendly staff and good music. Also really appreciated how welcome they were to us travelling with two dogs (brought them water, and found us a nice table in the corner). Food was great too. Highly recommended.

Osteria Bacerotti

4.6/5

23 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

TheForkUserIf you want to eat authentic and local made food, this is the place to eat! Amazing food quality, good and helpful service, fair price/value: many thanks!

Ristorante Salsì

4.8/5

41 Reviews

$$-$$$

Reservation Available

Seafood

TheForkUserWe like it very much the all family was happy.

Il Bargello

4.2/5

5 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

_TI***2uThis restaurant offers a lovely atmosphere with beautiful views. The pizza is light and delicious, making it a great spot for a casual meal.

Pizzeria la rotonda morrovalle

3.8/5

5 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

_TI***2uThe restaurant has a lovely interior and a cozy vibe. The pizza is light and crispy, and the menu also includes a nice selection of grilled specialties and burgers.

Pizzeria Aix

3.8/5

5 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

_TI***b8The thin and crispy pizza here is well-cooked and seasoned to perfection. It's a great spot for gatherings with friends, though the decor feels a bit nostalgic.

Ristorante Pizzeria Da Bosio

3.4/5

5 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

_TI***uwThe pizza here is absolutely sublime! The crust is perfectly cooked, and the toppings are generous and flavorful. Highly recommend it!

Trattoria Passo d'Acera

4.6/5

14 Reviews

$$-$$$

Western-style

TheForkUserSuperb little restaurant on a mountainside. No English spoken but had menu in English on line, so easy. Owner very friendly and food just great! My husband had the best pork he’s ever had!

My Way Pizzeria

4.8/5

50 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

Ristorante La Basilica

4/5

12 Reviews

$

Western-style

Il Cocco di Mamma

4.2/5

11 Reviews

$

Western-style

Osteria del Corso

5/5

1 Reviews

$

Western-style

Il Goloso Bistrot

4.5/5

6 Reviews

$$-$$$

Western-style

TheForkUserMy family and I were visiting Perugia from Texas and we heard great things from many locals about Il Goloso Bistrot, so we had to visit. Upon arriving we were greeted by Valentina right away and she made us feel at home. We visited on a Thursday, which turned out to be pizza night. Valentina set us up at a nice table in their very warm and inviting dining area. Valentina and the staff served us an amazing variety of pizzas and beer--our favorite was the Margarita (it is hard to beat a classic), even though every option was similarly amazing. Overall, the service was amazing, the atmosphere was very comfortable and the food was spectacular. We highly recommend Il Goloso Bistrot to all.

Extravergine Oleoteca in Piazzetta della Loggia

2/5

1 Reviews

$$-$$$

Western-style

Tenuta Baroni Campanino

4.8/5

11 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Western-style

TheForkUserWe had a wonderful lunch at Tenuta Baroni Campanino. It is only 20 minutes from Assisi on top of a mountain. The view is breathtaking. For a truly authentic experience with incredible scenery, food and wine. Don’t expect a full menu. Do expect exceptional sausages, hams and Meats paired with delicious cheeses. The wines are excellent and they have a craft beer line as well. The service was attentive and knowledgeable. Our three year old son had plenty of room to run around while we enjoyed our meal. Highly recommend if you are looking for a great lunch experience off the beaten track. My husband is Spanish and said their ham “is the best I’ve had outside Spain”. That’s saying something!!

La Piscina

4.2/5

257 Reviews

$

Western-style

TheForkUserThe staff were very friendly and helpful

La Maestà

5/5

3 Reviews

$

Western-style

Ristorante La Tavola Dei Cavilieri

4.7/5

21 Reviews

$

Western-style

TheForkUserIt was unbelievable! The hosts where amazing and they wanted us to have the best time of our life. And we did!???? But you have to be a good driver to get here.. the road is kinda scary????

Bertini's

4.8/5

10 Reviews

$

Seafood

Taverna San Nicolo

4.8/5

13 Reviews

$$-$$$

Western-style

TheForkUserThe best place to eat in Montecassiano. Amazing ambiance, great food, and nice service. We had a great time.

Il Roseto

No comments yet

Western-style

Gallo D’oro Ristoro Medievale

4.8/5

45 Reviews

$$-$$$

Reservation Available

Western-style

TheForkUserThe food was impeccable. Absolutely delicious and perfectly cooked. We ordered the lamb, potatoes, tiramisu and a flask of house wine to go with it. Everything was delicious. The lamb especially was cooked and seasoned to perfection. One of the best meat dishes we have tasted in a long time.

Osteria Panicaglia - Borgo Castello Panicaglia

5/5

4 Reviews

$$-$$$

Western-style

Rambaldus Spirits & Kitchen

4/5

9 Reviews

$$-$$$

Reservation Available

Western-style

Braceria Griglieria T'arrostisco

4.9/5

10 Reviews

$

Barbeque

La Fetuseria

4.6/5

5 Reviews

$

Reservation Available

Coffee Shops

_TI***13This restaurant offers a fantastic dining experience with a limited but expertly prepared menu. The service is excellent, making it a great choice for a special meal.