Service

I attended a charity event at Millpond Gatherings, and the food was outstanding! The staff was attentive and handled everything smoothly, making it a wonderful venue for events.

The ambience of the restaurant is truly enchanting, especially with the live piano music enhancing the dining experience. The view is spectacular, making it a perfect spot for a romantic dinner.

What a gem in downtown Westerly! The combination of great food, excellent service, and a beautiful atmosphere makes this restaurant a must-visit.

Planning a trip to Old Lyme? Discover the city's top-rated restaurants, based on authentic traveler ratings and reviews. ▸ See menus & photos ▸ Book tables instantly ▸ Get exclusive deals on Trip.com.

THE 10 BEST Restaurants in Old Lyme

Filter by

Establishment type

Meal type

Cuisines

Price

Online options & offers

Traveler rating

Business Hours

Dietary restrictions

Great for

Features

Recommend restaurants in Old Lyme for December

Old Lyme Inn

Johnny Rockets

Cedars Steaks & Oysters

Millpond Gatherings

Dattilo Fine Italian at Water’s Edge

The Cafe - Westerly

Burger King

Guilford Mooring Seafood

Tre Scalini Restaurant

Consiglio's Restaurant

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

Dog Watch Cafe

Sushi Kame

Michael Jordan's Steakhouse - Mohegan Sun

Cromwell Diner

Lobster Roll Restaurant

1770 House Restaurant & Inn

75 Main

Almond

Aspen Restaurant

The Farm Italy Mohegan Sun

Café Routier

Fresh Salt

Harbour House Restaurant

John Davenport's Restaurant

L'Orcio

Rooftop 120

Vine Street Café

Home Restaurant

Sadler's Ordinary

Common component