Love the old-school vibe here, feels like stepping back in time. The service is always friendly and efficient, which makes for a really relaxed meal.

Spacious inside and out, and they&rsquo;ve got a big private lot. That alone makes it a solid pick when you just don&rsquo;t want to hunt for parking.

Been coming here for years, and the pizza never disappoints. The crust is always perfectly crisp, and the cheese is so fresh. Honestly, it&#39;s my go-to spot in the neighborhood.

The steak sandwich here is simple but so satisfying. I like how the space feels open and airy, with those big windows letting in all the light. It&#39;s a nice spot to just sit and enjoy a meal without feeling rushed.

They always remember my name and what I usually order. It&rsquo;s that kind of personal touch that makes you feel like a regular, even if you&rsquo;re not. Really nice vibe.

The grilled octopus was pretty good, tender with a nice char. Seafood pasta was decent too. It&#39;s a cozy spot, though a bit on the pricey side.

Great spot on Main Street for a casual bite. I grabbed a drink at the bar and really liked the energy there. The vibe was just right.

Rose was a total blast, super energetic and really made our night. The food was solid, and honestly the view is just insane. Prices felt fair for what you get. Solid spot.

The salmon was really fresh, and they had these pretty fresh flowers on the tables. It was a nice, bright space for our group.

The garlic knots here are seriously good. So soft and buttery, with just the right amount of garlic. We also tried the calamari, which was crispy and not rubbery at all. Portions are huge for what you pay, which is always a plus.

Nice open space inside, felt comfortable. Food was decent, nothing fancy but reliable. Good option for a straightforward meal on the island.

Been coming here for years. The portions are always generous, never feel like you&#39;re getting shortchanged.

The private event space upstairs was perfect for our group. Marissa helped with everything, made it so easy.

The Chicken Diabla Chimichanga was fantastic. The chicken was juicy, the sauce had a nice smoky heat. Best margarita I&#39;ve had in Connecticut, hands down. Perfectly balanced, not too sweet.

The burger was hand-packed with a nice smoky flavor. Fries and nachos were hot and crispy, which was perfect. Service was quick, so we weren&#39;t waiting around.

Cozy spot with a nice back patio. Feels like a hidden gem. The food quality is solid, honestly rivals some places I&#39;ve tried in bigger cities. Perfect for a quick, quiet bite.

This is a solid spot in the area. The menu is a fun mix&mdash;you can get a classic NY strip, a plate of pasta, and really fresh sushi all in one place. The vibe is definitely upscale but still relaxed.

Easter dinner here. The lamb was cooked just right, tender and flavorful. Service was on point too. Really liked the cozy vibe of the place.

The salsa verde here is fantastic. They make it fresh daily, you can taste the tomatillos. It&#39;s got a bright, tangy kick that&#39;s just right. I get extra every time for my chips. The roja is good too, but the verde is the star.

The scallops and mussels were solid, but a couple other plates missed the mark for me. Good beer list though.

Our server was super helpful with suggestions! We got the steak tidbits and lobster mac and cheese to share with the table. The mac and cheese was so rich and creamy, perfect for passing around. Cocktails from the bar were solid too.

That fried chicken and waffles is the real deal. The batter has a nice sweet touch, and the chicken stayed super juicy under the crispy crust. Waffles were fresh and fluffy. Tried the sweet corn nuggets too &ndash; pretty unique and tasty.

The spicy watermelon margarita was the star for me. Had it on their deck with that killer bay view on a warm night. The sweet heat combo was just right. A little pricey for one drink, but totally made the evening.

Idalmis was so attentive with our big group. The space itself is cozy and inviting, which made the whole evening really pleasant.

As a Brooklyn guy, I can confirm this is legit pizza. The crust is buttery and flaky with a perfect snap. Never leave a crumb.

The AYCE sushi is such a steal! Fish is always fresh, and I&#39;m a big fan of their nigiri. Perfect for when you want to hang out with friends and eat a ton without stressing about the bill.

The Kurosawa sake is so smooth, definitely my favorite from their list.

Lunch by the water was so nice. The waitress tipped us off about the lobster tacos - they&#39;re not on the menu but absolutely worth asking for. My new favorite thing here.

Find and book the best Restaurants in Selden. Read authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and reserve your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Restaurants in Selden

Zuppardi's Apizza

Turkish Kebab House

Satelite Pizza

Gray Goose

Mama Lisa Restaurant

Avino's Italian Table

Main Street Cafe

Whales Tale

Country House

Uncle Joe's Pizza

Pines Bistro

Trips' Restaurant

BJ Ryan's

Tacos Mexico

Six Thirteen

Bereket Turkish Restaurant

Tony's at the J House

The Cottage

Four Burritos Diner

Tullulah's

El Primo Taqueria & Pupuseria

Drift 82

5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles

Whalers

Te Amo Tequila Bar & Tacos

Pappas Pizza

Sushi X2

Kotobuki

Hibachi Sushi Ya

Flynn's Fire Island