Establishment type
Meal type
Cuisines
Dishes
Price
Online options & offers
Traveler rating
Business Hours
Dietary restrictions
MICHELIN Guide
Features
Neighborhood
Updated in 2026
based on 71 reviews
_TI***znThe atmosphere in this restaurant is lovely, and the food is usually top-notch. I appreciate the effort the staff put into making sure everything runs smoothly.
_TI***fnThis place offers a great deal on weekends with two courses for £25. The food was delightful, and the staff were very attentive.
_TI***dbI highly recommend Toby Carvery for anyone craving a hearty meal. The food is always fresh and hot, and the customer service is top-notch, making it a reliable choice for a great dining experience.
TheForkUserWe had a friendly welcome. Staff were very friendly and helpful all evening. Lovely relaxed atmosphere food and service very good.
TheForkUserExcellent, warm, friendly service. Food was absolutely delicious. It was my husbands birthday and they made us feel so special.
TheForkUserFirst time here for many years. Great food, great service and good selection of beer's etconly one grumble, ordered a side dish of Dauphinoise potato's somewhere around the £3 mark. they arrived welded into a small ramakin dish and nice as they were there wasn't much more than a desert spoon full. Otherwise very happy an would recommend.
TheForkUserWe have been many times to Punch carvery The staff are efficient Ambience very good The staff always try to arrange seating to our satisfaction The food is as good as any carvery and better than most Always wish to continue returning
TheForkUserReally friendly service. The carvery was all quite fresh, gammon turkey pork beef and lamb to choose from. Vegetables were good especially roast potatoes, we will definitely be back!
TheForkUserPerfection The food was lovingly prepared, delicious and welcoming. The staff were friendly and the setting was comfortable.
TheForkUserA get together with a friend, lovely Sunday lunch. Pub very busy. We booked our table which I would recommend. Our waitress was great, very attentive. The manager looked stressed! When extra tables had to be sorted out. Food very nice, hot and plentiful. I’d recommend Toby’s but Sunday is incredibly busy not that made our meal any less pleasant. Well with a visit.
_TI***bpI highly recommend this place for families! The food is delicious, and the environment is welcoming, making it a great spot for a Sunday lunch.
TheForkUserMy husband and I have been travelling from Sheffield to the Fork every Sunday for the last few weeks as we feel this is the best carvery we have visited, and we've visited many places. The service, food and atmosphere are without a doubt excellent in every way. Well done to everyone concerned. You've got a great team !!!!
_TI***dlThis place is a hidden gem! The food is always fresh and well-prepared, and the service is top-notch. I highly recommend booking in advance, especially on weekends.
_TI***o4The atmosphere at this restaurant is lovely, and the food is excellent. It's a great place to enjoy a meal with colleagues or friends.
TheForkUserAsked for a quiet table with easy access, and got exactly that!The staff were welcoming and helpful and the food was a very good standard and generous portions.
_TI***1hI had a lovely Mother's Day visit at The Sovereign. The food was fresh and beautifully presented, and the attentive staff made the experience even more enjoyable.
_TI***lbEvery time I visit Toby Rotherham, I'm impressed by the quality of the food and the friendly service. The staff really go above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience.
_TI***2uI was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food at The Castle. The Signature Burger was absolutely amazing, and the staff, especially V, were knowledgeable and friendly.
_TI***h5I was really impressed with the value for money! The meal and drink deal for £10 was a steal, and the chicken burger was tasty and satisfying.
_TI***h3The restaurant has a lovely ambiance, and the food is consistently delicious. The attentive service makes every visit enjoyable, and I particularly appreciate the friendly staff who go the extra mile.
_TI***orThe afternoon tea was lovely, with fresh bread and warm scones. There was plenty to share, making it a great value for two.
TheForkUserUse Toby Cavery quite regularly. We find it reasonably priced, the food is always good and the staff are friendly and helpful. Would recommend this restaurant, but make sure you book as it gets really busy.
TheForkUserThe service was exceptional, the food was a very high standard and served on hot plates which most other restaurants fail to realise is the key to keeping the food warm
based on 491 reviews
_TI***dfWe had a brilliant time at the bottomless brunch! The cocktails were creative and the food was spot on. The service from Megan and Ash was friendly and efficient, making it a delightful experience.
TheForkUserWe only had starters with triple cooked chips.. Fabulous prawn cocktail and spicy chicken pieces.. that's all we wanted..a large snack really.. fabulous.
TheForkUserHad a lovely lunch with family, we asked to sit in a quieter area hence we're away from view of staff in a raised area - despite us being out of view the staff were very attentive making sure we had everything we needed. We would definitely eat at Fire Lake again