Had the blackened swordfish. The fish itself was so fresh, you could really taste it. The seasoning was light, which I appreciated. It came with a simple side of grilled vegetables, all very crisp. A nice, clean meal. The view from our window table was a bonus.

Service was pretty good. The staff was friendly and attentive. They even swapped the bun on my lobster roll for a thinner one when I asked. A nice touch.

The staff was so nice and attentive. Our waitress gave great suggestions, and when it got a bit cool outside, she brought over a heater without us even asking. Made the whole evening really comfortable.

The Nova Scotia eggs benedict had a generous portion of salmon, which was nice. Home fries were cooked just right.

Quick lunch spot. Got the chicken sandwich. Came out fast, which is key for me. Bread was fresh, chicken was decent. Not the cheapest but you pay for the speed. Good for a quick bite between meetings.

My usual spot in the neighborhood. The food is always solid&mdash;you know exactly what you&#39;re getting. The price is right for what&#39;s on the plate.

Becca and Eduardo were very attentive. Happy hour prices are solid, and the food is good. A nice spot for after work.

Really cozy spot. We had to wait a bit for a table, but the staff was super friendly about it. The booths are nice and roomy, which I always appreciate.

Pizza was solid. Shrimp was fresh, not rubbery. Crust had a nice char. Good spot for Italian in the area.

I&rsquo;m a burger person, and their double cheeseburger is one I keep coming back for. The patties are juicy, the cheese is melted just right. Tried adding chili once&mdash;really good. Their coffee milkshake is a solid choice to cut through the salt.

Came here with a big group for a friend&#39;s thing. The staff was so on top of it&mdash;never felt like we were waiting, even with a full table. Food was really good, but honestly, the smooth service made the night.

The food was solid and reasonably priced. Could have stayed for another beer if I wasn&#39;t in a rush.

Been coming here for years. Their sushi is always fresh, and they have some unique rolls you don&#39;t see at other spots. The plates look nice, too. A solid neighborhood choice.

Been coming here for years. They keep the quality consistent, which is what keeps me coming back. The open garage doors are a nice touch, especially in the evening. Food&#39;s always solid.

Cozy neighborhood spot with a warm vibe. The staff was genuinely friendly and checked in on us just the right amount, which made the whole meal feel relaxed and easy. A very comfortable place for a quiet dinner.

The French onion soup is really good. I had it with their house cabernet, a nice way to ease into the evening. The booths were comfortable, which made it easy to relax.

Ross is a master behind the bar. His spiced pineapple margarita had a perfect kick, and the smoked sunset was a real treat. Happy hour is the move for those.

Been coming here for years, and the sushi&#39;s always fresh. That eel sauce on the maki combo? Still the best in town. It&#39;s why I keep coming back.

The herb roasted chicken with mushroom risotto was very good. The risotto was the best part, creamy and flavorful.

Love the vibe here. It&#39;s rustic but still feels elegant, really warm and relaxing. We ended up staying for hours just chatting. The design is beautiful.

The personal pizza is a steal. Under $10 and you can load it up with whatever you want. I got mine with extra mushrooms and olives. The crust was just right, not too thick. Perfect for a quick lunch.

The gravy on the biscuits was the star. Rich, peppery, with just the right amount of sausage crumbles. Grits were creamy but could&#39;ve used a touch more salt. That&#39;s the only thing I&#39;d change.

The staff here is so nice and on top of things. Our server, Johnathan, was especially great&mdash;he remembered we were first-timers and gave us a few pointers on the menu. Made the whole dinner feel really easy.

Stopped by for lunch, sat on the patio. The vodka chicken pie was interesting, never had anything like it before. Pretty good.

The fish and chips here is the real deal. Perfectly crispy batter, flaky cod inside. The chips are thick-cut and actually taste like potato. That&rsquo;s what I come for.

Been coming here for years, service is always quick. The $30 bottomless mimosas are a solid deal for the area. Tried the passion fruit one this time, it was good. A reliable spot when you want a straightforward meal.

Find the best places for Dinner in Smithtown. Explore 1848 spots with authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and book your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Dinner in Smithtown

The Ritz Cafe

Crabby Amy's,

Trattoria Vivolo

Lake Grove Diner

Cherry's On The Bay

Osteria Romana

Bareburger

Adam's Rib Restaurant

Mario the Baker

Burgers, Shakes & Fries

La Nonna Bella

Prost Grill & Garten

360 Taiko Sushi & Lounge

Tula Kitchen

Rustic Root

Pine Grove Inn

Flinders Lane Kitchen & Bar

Mitsui Japanese Restaurant

LB Social

Tavern at GrayBarns

Pieology Pizzeria

Sweet Mama's

Pecado Mexican

Remo's

BRYAC Black Rock

Duchess Restaurant

Red Lotus Restaurant

The Cheesecake Factory

Village Idiot Pub

Gallo