We had a good stay overall. The location is excellent—it's close to the major Gettysburg attractions and within walking distance of the Gettysburg Outlets, including stores like Adidas, Talbots, Under Armour, and others. The rooms were also clean, comfortable, and well maintained.
The biggest disappointment was the breakfast. Calling it a "buffet" is generous—it wouldn't even qualify as a basic continental breakfast. There was no fresh fruit or even canned fruit at all, the yogurt selection was very limited and bland, there were no regular scrambled eggs (only an odd egg-based dish), just a couple of sugary cereals with regular milk, and a few muffins. The selection was so poor that we skipped breakfast entirely and ate elsewhere each morning.
If the hotel improved its breakfast, it would be an easy place to recommend.