Busy night but the staff was on point. My walleye came out flaky and just right, not dry at all. They kept things moving without feeling rushed.

The garlic stuffed tenderloin is always cooked just right. It&#39;s the one thing I keep coming back for. That flavor is just... spot on.

I always get the steak and cheese sub here. The bread is toasted just right, and the meat is never dry. It&#39;s my comfort food spot.

Been coming here for years, love the old-school vibe. That chocolate smell when you walk in is just the best. Their taffy is seriously underrated.

Been coming here for years. The food is consistently fantastic, especially the grilled octopus. It&rsquo;s always cooked perfectly, never rubbery. That&rsquo;s what keeps me coming back.

The staff was so nice about my gluten allergy. They checked everything and even suggested a couple dishes I could have. Felt really taken care of.

The old fashioned here is solid, and the portions are huge. Helps make up for the menu being a bit pricey.

Your ultimate guide to dining in Eagle River. Discover top-rated restaurants and local favorites, based on authentic traveler ratings and reviews. ▸ See menus & photos ▸ Find hidden gems ▸ Plan your perfect trip.

The best restaurants in Eagle River

The Timbers Bar and Grill

3C's Coffee Cup Cafe

PJ's Burger Barn

Knocker's Pizza Company Inc.

Sisters Saloon Inc

Bad Bones BBQ

McGregor's Blink Bonnie Supper Club

Clearview Supper Club

The Bear Trap Inn

Forest Lake Cafe & Wine Cellar

Subway

Dan's Minocqua Fudge

Northfork Fin & Filet

Kickback Grill

Mad Dog Jake's

Era Cafe Arbor Vitae

McNaughton Pub & Grill

White Stag Inn

Rustic Pines Pub

Honey Bear

DJ's Northwoods Family Restaurant

Pasty Corner

Fibbers Bar and Restaurant

Lumpy's Bar & Grill

The Guide's Inn

Hunan Chinese Restaurant

Culver’s

Friendship House Family Restaurant

Bucketheads Sports Bar & Grill

Cross Country Bar & Grill