The donuts are huge and so good. The black raspberry one is my favorite, even though I don&#39;t normally like jelly-filled.

The rehearsal dinner menu Brita helped us create was so thoughtful. I really appreciated the focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients for the summer theme. The grilled vegetables and the salmon were particularly good&mdash;you could tell everything was just picked or caught. It felt light and healthy, which was perfect for our group.

Cute little spot right off the boardwalk. Grabbed a coffee and sat outside for a bit. The breeze from the water was just right, not too strong. It&rsquo;s the kind of simple, quiet moment that just feels nice.

The pistachio cannoli was so good I had to get another one to take home. It was still perfect the next morning.

Love this old-school Italian bakery. Their sfogliatelle is the real deal - flaky, not too sweet, and the filling is just right. The espresso is strong and perfect with it. Gets busy on Saturday mornings, but the line moves fast.

Tried the red velvet waffle cone. It&#39;s a fun twist, the flavor actually comes through. Presentation is neat, like they put some thought into it. A bit pricier than your regular cone though.

The snickerdoodle cookie is warm and soft in the middle. The deluxe salted caramel is also fantastic.

Been coming here for years, and their babka is the reason. Always consistent, never dry. Grabbed a slice this morning with my coffee, and it&#39;s just as good as the first time. That&#39;s what keeps me coming back.

Just stumbled off Route 1 and found this place. The sour cream old fashioned donut was so fresh and different. Totally made the stop worth it.

The baguette was fresh, and the jam had a nice homemade taste. The cold brew was smooth, a good match. Simple, but they do it right. Felt like a fair price for what you get.

The strawberry and sweet cream ice cream were fantastic - you can tell it&#39;s made in-house. Our custom cake was delicious, but the decoration was a little off from what we requested. Still, the flavors are spot on.

Been a regular for years. The jelly croissants are still pretty good, and I usually grab a coffee with them. The place feels a bit dated, but it&#39;s a solid neighborhood spot.

I&#39;m a big fan of their holiday cakes. The ingredients taste so fresh, especially the fruit fillings. The cupcakes are a nice treat too, not overly sweet. It&#39;s a good spot for something a little special.

Shock Ice Cream is such a cute find in that little alley off the main drag. Perfect spot to grab a cone with friends after shopping. Felt like we discovered a secret! The salted caramel was so good we all ended up getting it.

They fixed a last-minute cake mix-up right away, gave us a free one on the spot. The Marjolaine and chocolate mousse were both really good.

The bubble waffle cone is the star here. It&#39;s crispy, slightly sweet, and holds the ice cream perfectly without getting soggy. The matcha flavor inside was solid, not too bitter. A fun texture combo.

Find the best Bakeries in Mattituck with Trip.com. Read authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and find the perfect spot for your next meal.

The Best Bakeries in Mattituck

North Fork Doughnut Company

The Marketplace at Guilford Food Center

Gumdrops & Lollipops Candy & Ice Cream

Libby's Italian Pastry Shop and Italian Ice

Lucibello's Italian Pastry Shop

Gemelli Gelato of Hampton Bays

Insomnia Cookies

Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe

Beach Donut Shop

Levain Bakery

Ashley's Ice Cream

Montauk Bake Shoppe

Tate's Bake Shop

Shock Ice Cream

Ice Cream Cottage

Marjolaine Pastry Shop

Cohen's Bagel Company

Blue Duck Bakery Cafe Southold

Milkcraft New Haven

Panera Bread

Tony D's Craft Creamery

Pursuit of Pastry

Dagmar's Desserts

Ben & Jerry’s

Holbrook Bagel Bakery

Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe

Ashley's Ice Cream

Hen & Heifer

Frank & Son Bakery

Ralph's Famous Italian Ices of Greenport