The Cubano was spot on, salty ham and tangy pickles with that perfect crunch. Sweet potato fries were a solid side. Really enjoyed it with a cold lager, the crispness cut through the richness nicely.

The Reuben was solid, plenty of corned beef. Fries were crispy. Lunch was a good option for a quick business meeting nearby. Service was efficient.

Olivia was super friendly and kept an eye on our table. We got the Buffalo chicken bites and fried olives to start - both were solid. Cocktails were good, not too sweet. A nice spot for a casual bite.

The lobster roll was generously filled and reasonably priced. The booth seating was comfortable, which made the meal more enjoyable.

Stopped by for lunch and got the bacon cod Reuben. It&#39;s a good sandwich, not too heavy. Washed it down with a local IPA. Casual spot, decent for a quick bite.

Tried the restaurant week menu and really enjoyed it. Everything was tasty and nicely done. The seating was comfortable, which made for a relaxed meal.

The tomato pie was so refreshing. Just the right amount of cheese to let the flavor come through.

This wine bar is so cute, perfect for catching up with a friend. The server was super helpful picking out a wine since the list is huge! We tried a few small plates and honestly, each one was better than the last. Great spot.

Parking&rsquo;s a hassle, but the food keeps me coming back. Had the grilled salmon again last night&mdash;cooked just right, crispy skin, not dry at all. That&rsquo;s what matters.

James the manager really made sure everything was on point. Server was super helpful with the menu, knew his stuff. Quick and friendly service, no complaints. Got my food fast and got out fast. Just what you need.

Stopped in after checking out the lighthouse. The calamari was the real deal &ndash; fresh, not rubbery at all. Cooked just right. The staff was cool, pointed me toward a couple of good local beers to go with it. Solid spot for a quick bite.

Love this spot for a quick vegan bite in Montauk. The iced tea was super refreshing after a beach day. Perfect for grabbing something light with friends before heading out.

Stopped by for lunch on a Montauk day trip. The location is super convenient, right off the main strip. I got the fish tacos&mdash;really fresh and crispy. Portion was decent for the price. A solid spot to refuel without going out of your way.

The view is everything here. Had a drink at the bar and watched the sunset over the water. The setting is just stunning. A bit pricey for what you get, but you&#39;re paying for that view.

The staff here is so nice! They really know the menu and were super attentive all night. It made our girls&#39; night feel so easy and relaxed. The valet and coat check were a nice bonus too.

We were a big group on a packed Saturday. The server handled our drink orders perfectly, never letting a glass go empty. That kind of attention with a full house is appreciated.

The margaritas are the real deal here. Got one during happy hour and it was huge, plus it actually had a kick to it. That&#39;s a solid combo you don&#39;t always find.

Huevos rancheros were solid. Quick service, got my order in and out fast. Perfect for a lunch break. The garden patio is a nice touch, good spot to eat. Would grab a quick bite here again.

Love how chill this place is for takeout. The food&rsquo;s always fresh and ready right when I get there. Prices are nice and low, so I keep coming back.

I&#39;m usually picky about my martinis, but theirs is solid. The oysters with that cucumber vinaigrette were so good we got a second round.

First time here, had the lobster quesadilla. The edges were so crispy, but the inside was still creamy and warm. That guacamole on the side really made it.

The clam chowder is the reason to come. Rich, creamy, and the clams don&#39;t overpower it. The veal osso buco was tender and well-executed. Solid spot for a business lunch downtown.

Cozy spot, feels like a little country inn. They switch up the decor with the seasons, which is a nice touch. The vibe is warm and relaxed, perfect for a low-key dinner. Just a really comfortable place to be.

The French toast with butterscotch bananas was the star. Perfectly crisp outside, soft inside, not overly sweet. The apple doughnuts were good, but honestly, the toast stole the show. I&#39;d go back just for that.

House-made pasta was the highlight. Fresh herbs and crisp vegetables in every bite. Portions were appropriate for the price. Service was efficient, got us in and out for a business lunch.

Crab cakes were the star here. Crispy outside, really flavorful inside. 👍

The paper tablecloths and crayons were a lifesaver for the kids. Kept them busy while we waited.

Grilled sea bass with cream sauce, asparagus, and leeks. The sear on the fish was spot on, really nice. That one was a standout for me.

The waitress was so friendly and made us feel right at home. She gave some really good suggestions for what to order, which made choosing easy. It&rsquo;s nice when the staff is attentive without being overbearing.

A solid neighborhood spot. The New Haven style crust is crisp, the sauce has a nice tang. Quality toppings. The patio is a pleasant spot to eat. Pizza is always ready for pickup, which is convenient. A reliable choice.

Find and book the best Restaurants in Mattituck. Read authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and reserve your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Restaurants in Mattituck

Pa's Place

Andy’s Restaurant | Greenport New York

South Edison

Guilford Lobster Pound

Westbrook Lobster Restaurant and Bar

Tre Scalini Restaurant

Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana

Barcelona Wine Bar

Shake Shack New Haven

Lombardi's on the Bay

Pizza Village

Naturally Good

668 The Gig Shack

Dockers Waterside Marina & Restaurant

Stone Creek Inn

RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum Bar

Blue Parrot

Estia's Little Kitchen

Cilantro's Mexican take-out

1770 House Restaurant & Inn

75 Main

Aspen Restaurant

Cooperage Inn

Heirloom

L'Orcio

Page Sag Harbor

Painters' Restaurant

Pierre's

ZINC

One6Three