Solid pub, and the Old Fashioned was spot on. Bartenders were on top of things even during the playoff rush!

The fish and chips here is the real deal. Perfectly crispy batter, flaky cod inside. The chips are thick-cut and actually taste like potato. That&rsquo;s what I come for.

Been coming here for years, service is always quick. The $30 bottomless mimosas are a solid deal for the area. Tried the passion fruit one this time, it was good. A reliable spot when you want a straightforward meal.

Bagels have a strong character, dough with real integrity. Sandwich craftsmanship is at its peak. Got the classic lox on my lunch break. Came out fast, hit the spot. Perfect quick bite.

Been here a few times now. The food is always the highlight for me. The steak is cooked just right, and the fish is super fresh. It&#39;s a solid spot for a reliable meal.

The baguette was fresh, and the jam had a nice homemade taste. The cold brew was smooth, a good match. Simple, but they do it right. Felt like a fair price for what you get.

A bit pricey but the donuts are huge and so fluffy. You can tell they&#39;re fresh because they&#39;re still warm when you get them.

Line moves fast. Staff is mostly friendly. Had one server who seemed a bit off, not as helpful as the others. But overall, they get you in and out.

Their special event wine pairing was a highlight. The sommelier explained each pairing in a way that was actually interesting, not just a lecture. Made the whole dinner feel more thoughtful.

Just tried their smoothie. Really fresh, tasted like they used local ingredients. The food looked good too, but I was just grabbing a quick drink. Solid spot for that.

The breakfast sandwiches are solid, but the seating area feels a bit cramped. Good for a quick bite.

The sushi was solid for a quick lunch with friends. Our server was super nice and kept things moving.

Dora was so sweet, checked on us a few times without hovering. The new menu items are a nice change, I tried the grilled octopus salad. It was fresh, but the portion felt a bit small for the price. Still, her service made the visit.

Olivia was super friendly and kept an eye on our table. We got the Buffalo chicken bites and fried olives to start - both were solid. Cocktails were good, not too sweet. A nice spot for a casual bite.

The steak with chimichurri sauce was the star for me. The chimichurri was super fresh and herby, really made the perfectly cooked steak pop. The oysters were a nice, briny start. Solid spot for a good meal.

Brought our own fresh catch, and they cooked it tempura and General Tao&#39;s style. Both dishes were pretty good, and the presentation was nice. The &quot;you hook &#39;em, we cook &#39;em&quot; idea is a decent one. Service was a bit slow, though.

The Montauk roll was fantastic, and the spicy lobster roll was just as good. Everything tasted so fresh.

Been coming here for over 20 years. The staff is the main reason. They remember your name, ask about the family. Makes it feel like a neighborhood spot. The rum punch is still good, too.

The banana Oreo ice cream here is so good. It&rsquo;s homemade and has that perfect creamy texture. The whole place just feels like a cozy, old-school spot.

Stopped in after checking out the lighthouse. The calamari was the real deal &ndash; fresh, not rubbery at all. Cooked just right. The staff was cool, pointed me toward a couple of good local beers to go with it. Solid spot for a quick bite.

Been coming here for years, and the swordfish piccata is why. It&rsquo;s always that fresh, flaky texture with the right hit of lemon and capers. Never had a bad one. That consistency keeps me coming back.

Love this spot for a quick vegan bite in Montauk. The iced tea was super refreshing after a beach day. Perfect for grabbing something light with friends before heading out.

Nice lunch on the patio overlooking the marina. The fried flounder sandwich was fresh, portion was just right. Fries were well-seasoned. Good spot for a relaxed business lunch. Service was prompt.

The chef&#39;s tasting menu was a fun surprise. I loved not having to decide and just getting to try a little bit of everything. The small plates kept coming, and each one was a cool little discovery.

The lobster was tender and the baked clams oreganata are a must-try. Seafood is consistently fresh here.

Just what I needed after a long hike. Grabbed the fish and chips. Came out quick, fish was fresh and crispy. Solid portion too. Menu looks big, gotta try the soft shell crab sandwich next time.

Cute little spot. The grilled octopus was cooked just right, tender with a nice char. The pasta was a bit too al dente for my taste, but the sauce had good flavor.

Planning a Suffolk County trip? Discover the best restaurants in Suffolk County with traveller reviews, ratings, menus, photos and exclusive dining deals. Book tables instantly on Trip.com.

The best restaurants in Suffolk County

Founders Tavern

Village Idiot Pub

Gallo

Goldberg's Famous Deli & Restaurant

Ancient Ginger

Maria's

Levain Bakery

Grindstone Coffee & Donuts

O Sole Mio NY

Jack’s Stir Brew Coffee

Sen

Beth's Cafe

Katrinka’s Deli

Tony's Fusion West

Arooga's Sports Tavern and Game Room

South Edison

Duryea's Montauk

Star Island Grill

Inlet Seafood Restaurant

Topside Montauk

John's Drive-In

Pizza Village

Harvest on Fort Pond

Naturally Good

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

Maroni Cuisine

Feed and Grain

Hooked

flora

The Dimon Estate