The server was really attentive, and the wine pairing was spot on. Good place for a birthday dinner.

The Garbage Plate is a beast of a meal, seriously filling. Got the chicken and hamburger versions to try. The chicken one was my pick, messy and satisfying. Portions are huge, definitely shareable.

Been coming here for years. The garbage plate is still the same, and that&#39;s a good thing. The whole place just feels familiar and comfortable, like a piece of Rochester you can count on.

Parking was surprisingly easy for downtown. Found a spot right out front. The street parking and nearby lots are a lifesaver.

Been coming here for years, and the fried fish sandwich is always solid. Can&#39;t beat the location either.

Been coming here for years, and Gio&#39;s always got the right call. He remembered I liked the shrimp tacos last time and suggested them again. They&#39;re just as good as ever. That kind of consistency keeps me coming back.

Came for dinner. The steak was a bit overcooked and salty, but the calamari appetizer was solid. The space itself is really nice though, with a cozy vibe and comfortable seating.

Friday night, the place was buzzing. The ricotta starter was fantastic, and I found a really nice red by the glass that went perfectly with it. Staff were super friendly.

The pork chop is a standout. Cooked perfectly, so juicy and full of flavor. Honestly, one of the best I&#39;ve had in a long time.

Our server was really on top of things, and the owner stopping by was a nice gesture. I appreciated the wine list&mdash;found a nice Cabernet that went perfectly with the steak. Made for a relaxed evening.

The eggs benedict menu is solid. Tried the crab cake version, hollandaise was creamy but not too heavy. Mimosa flight is a fun idea, liked the blood orange one best.

First time here with friends. The focaccia bread was so fresh and warm, you could tell it was made in-house. I had the Chicken Milanese, and the arugula salad on top was crisp and bright. Really appreciated that. The bartenders were super nice too.

Haven&#39;t been back in ten years. The grilled octopus was spot-on, tender with a nice char. Service was quick and friendly. I&#39;ll be back much sooner this time.

The fish fry was huge and cooked just right, really tasty. The red snapper special was so colorful on the plate. Prices are easy on the wallet, which is nice.

Tony and the team are so warm. It&#39;s the little things, like remembering how I like my coffee. Felt like stopping by a friend&#39;s place, not just a restaurant.

Portions are generous and the flavors are spot on. It&rsquo;s not the cheapest, but I think the quality is there. I find myself coming back whenever I&rsquo;m in Rochester.

Stopped in for a late lunch. The pork chop with peach salsa was cooked just right, really juicy. Nice and relaxed spot, service was chill. Solid meal.

The focaccia changes every day, and it&rsquo;s a great way to start. Got a rosemary and sea salt one this time&mdash;warm, soft, and so good with the olive oil.

The Haystack Tavern Double with onion straws and Campfire Mayo was solid. The patty was juicy, and the sauce had a nice smoky kick. Garlic parmesan fries were a fun first try for me, though I wish the garlic flavor was a bit stronger. Service was friendly and on point.

The samosa chaat bowl was solid. Their house red was a surprisingly good match for the spices.

The staff was super friendly and helpful. They had a nice wine list that paired well with the food.

The buffalo chicken pizza was so good, crispy crust and just the right amount of heat. The owner stopped by our table, which was a sweet gesture. Really liked the vibe here.

The waitress was so nice and checked on us just the right amount. It does get packed though, so try to go early.

Find and book the best Restaurants in Victor. Read authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and reserve your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Restaurants in Victor

Flight Wine Bar

Pomodoro Grill

Nick Tahou Hots

Steve T. Hots & Potatoes

Proietti's Italian Restaurant & Catering

Fedele's Brook House

Edibles Restaurant and Bar

Pelican's Nest Waterfront Restaurant

TRATA: The Restaurant At The Armory

Tony D's

Branca Midtown

Horizons Modern Kitchen + Wine Bar

Peppermints

Bocaccini's Italian Bistro

Casa De Pasta

Gateway Grille

Il Posto Bistro

Plum Garden Japanese Restaurant

Mamasan's

Char Broil Family Restaurant

ROAM Cafe

Galleria Pizza

Cure

Roots Cafe

Lento Restaurant

Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews

India House Express

California Rollin II Sushi Bar

Naples Wood Fired Pizza & Smokehouse BBQ

3 Legged Pig BBQ Real Pit BBQ