2024 Reviews: Key Colony Beach Motel Reviews from Real Guests.

Absolute gem. Impossible to beat the price and location. The motel is on the sand, it has a beautiful white sand beach which is not a given in the keys. The room was immaculately clean, the beds comfy and the linens spotless. I keep pinching myself, a place like this for the price we payed seems like a dream. As a Florida resident, I plan to make this a regular get away spot. This is the best value in all the keys, for sure.

Best hidden gem in Marathon. Refreshing non- corporate plce to stay. Very clean and price very affordable. We made reservations at last minute and were surprised there was availability due to mini lobster season going on. We recommend this place over any chain hotels. The beach /tiki shade area/ pool were cleaned everyday. A/C worked great, maintenance staff were actually cleaning the filters...you don't see that happening everyday! Best advice, book directly with hotel and save even more.

Oh my gosh where to start …. The location was great , its older but clean as a pin ! Beach beautiful ! Quiet , 20 steps to the beach from our ground floor room . The patio , solar lights at night , fantastic pool , lots of chairs and tables … can’t say enough !! LOVED IT !!!!!!! PS .. staff were very efficient and friendly .

Booked for 1 night to check out the area as we are heading on a cruise and wanted to be out of Ft Lauderdale. The price is high for the quality. The room was clean, the plastic is still on the lamps…and staff friendly. The motel is dated, the walls and ceiling are paper thin, so we could hear everything the people around and above us said. It was very loud with guests not observing quiet hours. The wall plugs didn’t all work and the ceiling is painted plywood. The decor has not been upgraded, there were only 3 pillows for 2 people and those were flat. The AC was very loud, making it difficult to sleep. This hotel should be avoided if you are looking for value for money and a quiet nights sleep.

Clean and basic but outside is why you come to the keys! Pool was perfect and a great view of the ocean. The beach area had many tables and beach loungers as well. For an affordable trip and family friendly as well you can't beat this non chain motel!