2025 Reviews: The Pitcher Inn Reviews from Real Guests.

Just lovely for our mini-honeymoon. The staff were terrific. The room was lovely, although for the price, we were expecting it to be larger. Great bed and bathroom. But the food was outstanding. The included breakfasts were great, and they went out of their way to be GF for my husband. And the dinner in the main restaurant was five star. When we were 'displaced' from a parlor, the owner allowed us to take over the pub, sent us tea and gave us a beautiful bottle of wine. Highly recommend.

Everything was absolutely perfect from start to finish. The service was impeccable and we love the staff. The food was exceptional and we love the prix fixe. Pitcher Inn is absolutely our favorite fine dining place!!

The Pitcher Inn is our go-to place in New England. This was our third stay although our last stay was 15 years ago. We cannot say enough the Inn. It is elegant, charming, friendly and just the perfect place to kick-back for a few days. Tracks, the casual restaurant, was very good. We did not eat at the main dining room this time. Breakfasts were different each day and wonderful. We cannot say enough about the staff - in particular, Jeffrey, Mehnaz, Heather and the general manager (whose name I do not recall). All of them were amazingly helpful and fun to deal with. As with our previous stays, the Pitcher Inn was great. And, don’t miss the Warren Store across the street. It has great great sandwiches and pastries.

They used to be well regarded and have become the worst lodging in Vermont. Shame on them for allowing what is happening to occur in their establishment. The good people of Vermont, a welcoming, diverse community deserve better than what they are doing to the area.

This place feels icky now.... not sure why you would allow such a deplorable person to stay in such a magnificent place. Extremely disappointed. We have had many great times in the past, even living in Vermont ourselves.... Very sad that we will never come back again.